Review of NANAY, TATAY: A Daughter's Death

October 31, 2024

One year ago, Malena Imperial (Elia Ilano), a sweet girl who loved the color pink and played the piano very well, suddenly collapsed and died during her 13th birthday party.  Her parents, Lino (Jeffrey Hidalgo) and Amanda (Andrea del Rosario), had been mourning the death of their only daughter ever since. Retired physician Amanda was especially affected, as memories of her dear departed Malena still haunted her everyday. 

One night, the couple encountered three young ladies on the street, running away from  someone. The girls --  Bettina (Aubrey Caraan), Paula (Heart Ryan) and Olive (Xia Vigor) -- claimed that just escaped from a criminal syndicate. Taking pity on them, Amanda offered the three to go home with them, which the three accepted right away. The next morning, Amanda asked them if they would like to stay and become their daughters.  

This new Filipino horror film was written and directed by Roni S. Benaid. All of Benaid's previous feature films were in the horror genre -- "Poon" (2018), "Mary Cherry Chua" (2023) and "Marita" (2023). Like in his last two films which I watched, Benaid relied mainly on loud blasts of creepy music and sudden startling sound effects to cause jump scares. But he did have some good scares, like Paula's shower scene where the audience reacted most.

Benaid's screenplay actually had a number of good twists, not just one, and this kept the story interesting and unpredictable. A questionable plot point, like why did the three girls automatically agree to go home with the Imperials that first night, was actually explained by one of the twists.  A plot twist which they spoiled with dialog, like why did Lino cremate Malena first before bringing her home to Amanda, was actually a red herring for a bigger twist.

Acting-wise, Caraan tended to be too chill, Ryan tended to overact, Vigor tended to be too cutesy. Del Rosario and Hidalgo did well giving their roles enough air of uncertain mystery so as not to give the whole plot away. Elia Ilano was such a brave child actress to portray a role like Malena which required her to go into Linda Blair territory and beyond. I hope she was properly debriefed by a child psychiatrist after shooting those gnarly scenes.  6/10