November 18, 2026
Elizabeth Holmes was the founder and CEO of Theranos, a company that promoted a device called Edison, that was supposedly able to run multiple laboratory tests accurately on a single drop of blood. In 2015, the validity of her claims were called into question, leading her to be sued and convicted for fraud. It was during this period of litigation in 2017 that she met businessman Billy Evans. The couple moved in together in 2018, and bore a son in 2021.
In 2022, Holmes was found guilty of defrauding her investors. She was sentenced to imprisonment of 11 years and 3 months. In 2023, 34 days before she began her sentence, Holmes and Evans invited filmmakers Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim to film a documentary about them. The aim was to clearing Holmes' name by showing how she actually was in real life, filming from their rented beach house in Del Mar, California.
I did not hear or know anything about Holmes or Theranos at all until I watched this documentary film. I only knew about this documentary because of the critical acclaim and awards buzz about it since it was premiered at the Telluride Film Festival in September. It has since been on wide release distributed by A24. It has now earned more than $60M in the US and Canada alone, very impressive given its original budget was only $7M.
For someone who went to watch this film totally blind, the first thing that struck me about Elizabeth Holmes were her eyes. The way that her eyes were always opened widely, staring, seemingly unblinking, was unsettling to see. For someone who was supposed to project a good image with this film, she instead gave off a very uncomfortable vibe about her. There was always this nagging feeling that this woman we see was not really the REAL Elizabeth.
Billy Evans projected a slimy, narcissistic vibe from the get go. He was evasive when Nathan was asked him why he pursued Elizabeth even if she was being litigated. When Elizabeth was already in jail, the manipulative monster within Billy emerged full force -- from launching his own diagnostic lab company, taking over Elizabeth's AI image and social media, to brazenly negotiating for a percentage of the documentary's financial gains.
An interesting aspect of this film was the reenactment of scenes which Fiedler had not caught on camera featuring actress Amanda Seyfried, who played Elizabeth in a miniseries "The Dropout" in 2022. Seyfried was not always "on script" in her portrayal, as she stated her own opinions about the case as she argued with actor Christopher Abbott (as Billy). With Seyfried's role in this, how can we be sure about the truth Nathan was supposedly telling us?
Whose truth had we witnessed then? Did the title deliver? Have we really seen everything? 8/10

No comments:
Post a Comment